Packaging Papers

Still searching for the labor shortage?

Written by Hugh Murphy | Nov 18, 2026, 3:57:19 AM

In October 2021, Americans typed "labor shortage" into Google 49,500 times. Last month it was 1,900.

Our team was chatting today about a story with an economist's perspective on apple stocks that had doom and gloom to say about "not enough people" in America. Intrigued and looking for an angle to link to our proposition on helping clients save labor in their packaging operations, I went looking for data. For nearly 20 years now, I've been intrigued about the ability for search data to cast a new light on stories and peel the onion a little more behind the headlines. So, expecting to find a market worried about finding people, I dug into what people are searching for online. For not the first time, I found the opposite. Averaged over a year, searches for "labor shortage" are down 90% since 2022. "Sign on bonus" is down 62%. "Employee retention" is down 66%. Over the same four years, searches for "warehouse jobs" more than tripled.

By the internet's reckoning, the crisis is over. The workers came back and the worry went away.

Nobody is making big capital investments either

The same quiet shows up in equipment. Searches for palletizers are flat since 2022. Stretch wrap machines are down 21% and strapping machines down 28%. This year, searches for equipment leasing fell by nearly half and equipment financing by a third.

The big, whole-line automation had its moment first. Searches for robotic palletizers more than tripled in the year to October 2025, then fell 59% in the year since. Warehouse automation fell 44% and case packers 48%. Taken as a group, the big-system terms I tracked are now 15% below where they were in 2022.

One corner of the data is moving the other way

Searches for semi-automatic case sealers have more than doubled since 2022. Turntable stretch wrappers have nearly tripled. Water-activated tape dispensers are up 81%. Automatic bagging machines are up 70%, and have risen every single year.

These are small numbers: 57, 141 and 1,220 searches a month across the whole country for the first three. And none of it is robots. It reads like plants deciding that two people should not spend a shift taping boxes and walking film around a pallet.

As a group, this first-step equipment is up 79% since 2022, and it kept climbing straight through the year the big systems fell back.

Two kinds of automation

I think the two lines are answering different questions. A robotic palletizing cell is a bet on the future. It needs a worried management team, a capital budget and someone willing to finance it, and this year all three went quiet together.

A case sealer or a bagging machine is a response to today's arithmetic. It does not need a labor crisis to make sense. Applicants being easy to find does not make hand-taping a good use of a wage.

About 555,500 Americans pack by hand, at a median wage of $36,280. The Bureau of Labor Statistics expects 27,500 fewer of them by 2035, and gives the reason plainly: packers have fewer manual tasks as technology in warehouses and packaging facilities evolves. [1]

The people who count workers have not relaxed

In April, two Federal Reserve Board economists wrote that the US labor force could stop growing this year. Last year the economy needed about 85,000 new jobs a month to hold unemployment steady. This year, they estimate, it could need fewer than 10,000, because the pool of available workers is barely growing. [2]

The Census Bureau has counted one reason why. Net international migration fell from 2.7 million to 1.3 million in a single year, and the Bureau projects about 321,000 by mid-2026. [3]

It is sharper in the Upper Midwest

Wisconsin's own projections show the population aged 25 to 64 falling by nearly 200,000 this decade, a 6.6% drop. More than 25,000 were already gone by 2024. Over the same decade the number of people 65 and over rises by almost 283,000. [4]

Minnesota's labor force shrank 0.7% in the year to April. [5]

None of this feels urgent on a plant floor today. In the Minneapolis Fed's most recent survey of manufacturers, more than half said labor availability had not changed, and about a third had cut headcount. [6] Hiring is easier than it was three years ago. The data looks like an explanation for exactly why the searches stopped.

What might we take from this

Search data measures attention, and attention has moved on. The demographic numbers measure something slower, and they have not moved on at all.

Big automation follows the mood, and the mood has gone. The hand-level kind follows the math of one job at one station, and that math has not changed. If the Federal Reserve's economists are right about the labor force, the plants replacing a tape gun this year are the ones quietly getting ready for it, whether or not that is why they are doing it.

What are these search numbers

Search figures are US Google Ads search volumes, pulled on 17 November 2026. Percentage changes compare average monthly searches for November 2021 to October 2022 with November 2025 to October 2026. Google rounds these volumes into bands, and 2022 was the peak of the post-pandemic hiring crunch, so the falls start from an unusually high point. The two groups in the big-versus-small chart are my own baskets of search terms, listed under the chart.

Sources

  1. US Bureau of Labor Statistics, Occupational Outlook Handbook: Hand Laborers and Material Movers, updated 27 August 2026.
  2. Seth Murray and Ivan Vidangos, Labor force growth, breakeven employment, and potential GDP growth, FEDS Notes, Federal Reserve Board, 2 April 2026.
  3. US Census Bureau, U.S. Population Growth Slows Due to Historic Decline in Net International Migration, 27 January 2026.
  4. Jacob Anderson, Not Enough: Wisconsin's Housing Outlook, Forward Analytics, May 2026, using Wisconsin Department of Administration projections.
  5. Oriane Casale and Nick Dobbins, Signs of Stress: Minnesota's Labor Market 2026, Minnesota Department of Employment and Economic Development, June 2026.
  6. Joe Mahon, Manufacturers remain optimistic after another down year, Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis, 4 February 2026.